To provide guidance on this issue, a student workshop was held on non-academic career opportunities, with a panel of five researchers from government, industry and non-governmental organizations sharing their experiences. Students challenged the panel with questions regarding freedom of research, funding options and censorship in non-academic jobs.
Carissa D. Brown
Held from 14 to 17 May 2009, the joint meeting included more than 450 attendees from around the world, with more than 100 posters and over 250 talks. Although the CSEE is a young society with its first annual meeting held in 2006, its membership is now over 800, a growth rate of more than 30 per cent in the last year alone. Ecologists and evolutionary biologists repeatedly demonstrated the strength of collaborative research across disciplines, with many talks and posters incorporating molecular and ecological techniques. Combining CSEE with the Annual Conference of the GSC further strengthened the increasing integration of these disciplines.
Dalhousie University has a tradition of great strength in marine ecology and conservation, and the influence of one of Dalhousie’s famous marine researchers, the late Ransom (Ram) Myers, was apparent in several excellent talks. Results were presented from studies conducted at local to global scales, each with a similar and ominous thread: species continue to decline in many marine systems. This includes both shifts in the distributions of important commercial species, and indeed, the decline of entire communities that have undergone commercial exploitation. For example, in the North Sea, impacts of climate change are dramatic, with research showing that northern biogeographic boundaries of fish communities are moving in both latitude and depth below sea level by 4 m °C −1 of warming. Further, large-bodied fishes are being replaced by small-bodied species (caused mostly by fishing pressure, though some of the change is explained by warming waters). Other studies showed declines in species that have traditionally proven difficult to monitor (such as sharks and rays in the tropics) but can now be tracked with new volunteer-based techniques. Modelling exercises linking global fisheries and climate change demonstrated the susceptibility of national economies to changes in fish landings, especially in countries such as Colombia, Peru, Pakistan and much of the African continent.
In the Plant Reproduction and Mating Systems symposium, leading plant scientists presented new insights into evolutionary concepts such as bet-hedging traits and adaptive divergence. Testing mechanisms of adaptive diversification is challenging; nevertheless, many presentations showed important advances in this field. Experimental manipulations of, for example, Pseudomonas bacteria and vascular plant populations demonstrated scientists’ increasing knowledge of the links between competition, natural selection and diversity. Researchers also presented novel theoretical results, such as using computer simulations to investigate the evolution of habitat selection strategies. Other studies used known data on species ranges and phylogenies to build models for use in predicting species or community responses to climate change.
A third workshop centred on the SPECIES Project (Stability of Populations Evolving in Changing Integrated Ecological Systems). CSEE President Douglas Morris (Lakehead University) introduced the workshop by highlighting the growing mismatch between the need for research in ecology and evolution and the funds allocated for this research. This introduction was followed by a discussion (chaired by Sina Adl of Dalhousie University) of national and global research priorities and shortfalls. An extended workshop to develop appropriate national research and funding priorities will take place in the coming months at the Canadian Institute for Ecology and Evolution.
Participants in the Ecology and Evolution of Conservation Programmes symposium sought to challenge the classic view that evolutionary and ecological changes do not occur on the same time scale. Many talks framed conservation genetics in the context of applied evolution, showing ways that evolutionary processes can be manipulated to either enhance the conservation of threatened species or to decrease the spread and impact of invasive species. Several researchers called attention to the importance of genetic diversity in altering the dynamics of populations and communities, while others illustrated how genetic diversity within a species can have effects that are surprisingly large relative to the impact of species diversity in the functioning of communities. Modelling and empirical studies showed the importance of genotypic and phenotypic diversity in the performance of populations, notably in response to species invasions and climate change. An interesting conclusion of a study by Russell Lande (Imperial College) was that for invasive species, the fitness of the invading organism can change rapidly (over the course of a generation) owing to phenotypic plasticity, so that accurate predictions of the spread of invasive species require sampling over the appropriate time frame.
This CSEE meeting came at the end of the IPY, a worldwide research drive to explore polar regions. The IPY involved thousands of researchers, and this research was highlighted in several talks and posters as well as in a symposium. Given the rapid changes in polar climates and ecosystems, international collaboration on this research is essential. Research presentations covered, for example, global analyses of treeline movement and ITEX (International Tundra Experiment), experimental warming work showing dramatic responses in tundra ecosystems worldwide, in terms of both biogeochemical changes in carbon dioxide and methane production, as well as in rapid changes to community structure and species dominance. Several talks showed changes to ecosystem functioning at the landscape scale, and how this is having dramatic impacts on northern communities that depend on these resources. Much of this research was conducted in conjunction with northerners, as the IPY was explicitly designed to be in the service of northern communities.
Charley Krebs (University of British Columbia), the recipient of the inaugural CSEE President’s Award for Outstanding Contributions to Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, summarized an amazing lifetime of research on keystone taxa in the dominant northern ecosystems: lemmings drive the ecosystem dynamics in tundra and hares do the same in boreal forest. Krebs also highlighted the fact that Canada places low priority on ecology and evolution funding relative to other industrialized countries. This is very troubling to the many conference attendees who rely on Natural Science and Engineering Research Council grants for much of their research operating funds and is especially problematic for the new cohort of young researchers trained during the IPY. With most northern research funds now gone, both nationally and internationally, this training may be for nought. The penchant for cutting research funds during hard economic times (e.g. Brumfiel & Gilbert 2009; Hoag 2008, 2009) represents a waste of intellectual capital, especially expertise on climate change and the Arctic.
Ecology, evolution and genetics join together on Canada’s east coast Brian M. Starzomski School for Resource and Environmental Studies, Dalhousie University, 6100 University Avenue, Halifax,